
Rohinton Mistry it ain t - When I first picked up this Booker winner, I thought it was just like every other novel I d read about modern India, wallowing in self pity and weighed down by the colossal shoulder-chip of post-colonialism and the caste system.Perhaps I must take into account the author s tender years (he s 34ish), but I feel that a more life-experienced writer would have done more with the tale of a servile young man s corruption by the hot-headedness of the amoral business world.Having said that, it is nicely written with some very quotable one liners. But the editor s poor grasp of correct English ( bored of - forsooth!) is extremely disappointing.
Overrated - Poor story all around, no surprises here. I suppose the book would make for some sort of (poor) guide to India for someone who has no clue about the country. For everone else its a waste of time.The book dwells into the lives of the worst possible characters in any society. We don t need the book to tell us, that human society has a few of such kind in whichever country we may live. Complete waste of time.
it got me through a Christmas flu..... - I was dubious about a Booker but found this an easy and entertaining read - I felt for Balram Halwai and loved his humour in spite of what he had to endure at the hands of his employers ...but nothing changes and I thought the ending appropriate............
a cracking read - I have just finished The White Tiger by Aravind Adiga, winner of the man booker prize 2008.It was a cracking read - pacy and chilling, and I fear rather close to reality for some people... certainly illustrates some of the - good and bad - sides of new India and old India , poverty and opportunity (or lack of it)and the darker side of human nature.
Utterly hopeless - This is an utterly hopeless book. Hopeless in that it offers no hope whatsoever. It is beautifully written, very easy to read and gives a real sense of modern India. I don t know but one suspects that it, sadly, may be an accurate picture. None of the characters come across well, the while Indian situation is described in a way which portrays the society as fundamentally unjust, corrupt and rotten to the core. From a Christian perspective the book is a reminder to me of how lost human society is without Jesus Christ - and how secular humanism has nothing to offer as a solution. At the end of the book Balram indicates his desire to build a school of the poor children in Bangalore A school where you won t be allowed to corrupt anyone s head with prayers and stories about God or Gandhi - nothing but the facts of life for these kids. It is a bleak and depressing vision - not least because one of the facts of life is that sometimes murder is ok.....